Most Reviewed Psychological Horror Games Under $40

The most-reviewed Psychological Horror games for games under $40, ranked by total review count.

All Indie Action Adventure Simulation RPG Strategy Co-op Open World Story Rich Casual Funny Survival Difficult Pixel Graphics PvP Horror Anime Puzzle Rogue-like Relaxing Turn-Based Strategy Local Co-Op Psychological Horror Hack and Slash Platformer MMO RTS Immersive Sim Post-apocalyptic Action Roguelike City Builder Life Sim Zombies Sports Racing Survival Horror Stealth Bullet Hell Dungeon Crawler Visual Novel JRPG Deckbuilding Grand Strategy Cyberpunk Tower Defense Clicker Fighting Open World Survival Craft Boomer Shooter Colony Sim Farming Sim Cozy Auto Battler Cooking Twin Stick Shooter Metroidvania 4X Souls-like Dating Sim MMORPG

By price

Any priceFreeUnder $5Under $10Under $20Under $40
Our score adjusts Steam's raw rating for sample size. The fewer reviews a game has, the more its score gets pulled toward the site-wide average, so a tiny game can't fluke its way to #1.
  1. 1HELLDIVERS 275.16%
  2. 2Dead by Daylight78.58%
  3. 3Phasmophobia94.41%
  4. 4Geometry Dash92.94%
  5. 5Lethal Company96.78%
  6. 6Undertale96.16%
  7. 7People Playground98.07%
  8. 8Resident Evil 496.84%
  9. 9Content Warning93.50%
  10. 10Resident Evil Village94.96%
  11. 11Escape the Backrooms90.00%
  12. 12MiSide97.00%
  13. 13Outlast95.70%
  14. 14Metro Exodus89.66%
  15. 15Resident Evil 7 Biohazard94.55%
  16. 16Buckshot Roulette94.54%
  17. 17Little Nightmares94.01%
  18. 18My Summer Car94.17%
  19. 19The Outlast Trials92.05%
  20. 20Outer Wilds94.71%
  21. 21DEVOUR90.03%
  22. 22OMORI95.89%
  23. 23Gorilla Tag90.66%
  24. 24Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy82.64%
  25. 25WEBFISHING95.92%
  26. 26Alien: Isolation92.12%
  27. 27Outlast 290.19%
  28. 28OneShot96.52%
  29. 29CONTROL Ultimate Edition86.00%
  30. 30The Hungry Lamb: Traveling in the Late Ming Dynasty93.17%
  31. 31Five Nights at Freddy's92.55%
  32. 32Alan Wake89.30%
  33. 33Little Nightmares II91.94%
  34. 34NEEDY STREAMER OVERLOAD93.04%
  35. 35The Long Drive88.19%
  36. 36DREDGE94.22%
  37. 37Lobotomy Corporation | Monster Management Simulation92.84%
  38. 38Prey89.97%
  39. 39SOMA94.17%
  40. 40What Remains of Edith Finch93.92%
  41. 41Inside the Backrooms81.22%
  42. 42Firework95.41%
  43. 43Pacify86.01%
  44. 44Library Of Ruina92.73%
  45. 45Backrooms: Escape Together87.84%
  46. 46Life is Strange: Before the Storm91.63%
  47. 47Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc93.75%
  48. 48Mouthwashing93.23%
  49. 49Hand Simulator84.14%
  50. 50Blood and Bacon93.10%
  51. 51Amnesia: The Dark Descent92.56%
  52. 52Bendy and the Ink Machine88.16%
  53. 53City Car Driving83.30%
  54. 54The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe92.21%
  55. 55Sultan's Game91.93%
  56. 56Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk93.91%
  57. 57Superliminal92.45%
  58. 58The Evil Within85.22%
  59. 59SIGNALIS94.03%
  60. 60Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut94.09%
  61. 61Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair93.31%
  62. 62Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!94.13%
  63. 63The Evil Within 290.46%
  64. 64Tiny Bunny83.58%
  65. 65Hello Neighbor85.66%
  66. 66Hatred84.69%
  67. 67Layers of Fear (2016)87.61%
  68. 68Pro Soccer Online82.92%
  69. 69Sally Face - Episode One94.05%
  70. 70Chinese Parents89.72%
  71. 71Frostpunk 277.88%
  72. 72STEINS;GATE93.83%
  73. 73Five Nights at Freddy's 291.38%
  74. 74Darkwood92.15%
  75. 75Demonologist85.29%
  76. 76Cruelty Squad92.98%
  77. 77Amazing Cultivation Simulator85.57%
  78. 78The Beginner's Guide87.37%
  79. 79The Quarry83.06%
  80. 80The Texas Chain Saw Massacre71.92%
  81. 81Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony83.75%
  82. 82Fran Bow93.67%
  83. 83BIGFOOT83.11%
  84. 84Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk93.10%
  85. 85The Room Two93.70%
  86. 86港詭實錄ParanormalHK88.14%
  87. 87The Test92.97%