Hidden Gem Horror Games
Highly rated Horror games that never got big: under $20, fewer than 25,000 reviews. The review cap filters out everything you've already heard of.
All Indie Action Adventure Simulation RPG Strategy Co-op Open World Story Rich Casual Funny Survival Difficult Pixel Graphics PvP Horror Anime Puzzle Rogue-like Relaxing Turn-Based Strategy Local Co-Op Psychological Horror Hack and Slash Platformer MMO RTS Immersive Sim Post-apocalyptic Action Roguelike City Builder Life Sim Zombies Sports Racing Survival Horror Stealth Bullet Hell Dungeon Crawler Visual Novel JRPG Deckbuilding Grand Strategy Cyberpunk Tower Defense Clicker Fighting Open World Survival Craft Boomer Shooter Colony Sim Farming Sim Cozy Auto Battler Cooking Twin Stick Shooter Metroidvania 4X Souls-like Dating Sim MMORPG
By price
Our score adjusts Steam's raw rating for sample size. The fewer reviews a game has, the more its score gets pulled toward the site-wide average, so a tiny game can't fluke its way to #1.
- 1The Room 4: Old Sins18,37493.70%98.46%
- 2Fran Bow23,05393.44%97.41%
- 3The Room Two21,80793.36%97.53%
- 4Nubby's Number Factory19,60193.21%97.31%
- 5Grimm's Hollow14,61693.10%98.52%
- 6Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk22,39593.09%96.62%
- 7The Test20,11192.88%96.71%
- 8Tales of the Black Forest15,50492.72%97.59%
- 9Quake16,44392.19%96.45%
- 10Trombone Champ11,25392.08%97.91%
- 11Zup! S16,20892.03%96.83%
- 12NIGHT-RUNNERS PROLOGUE22,61491.96%94.96%
- 13missed messages.15,55391.79%96.03%
- 14The Walking Dead: The Final Season21,53991.63%95.06%
- 15Pony Island18,14791.48%94.95%
- 16LISA: The Painful15,19291.36%95.42%
- 1760 Seconds! Reatomized19,63791.32%94.44%
- 18Cube Escape: Paradox12,23991.31%97.06%
- 19Detention11,82890.87%95.69%
- 20Samsara Room10,23990.78%97.14%
- 21The Past Within16,85690.77%94.63%
- 22CULTIC8,73590.75%97.12%
- 23Kindergarten10,64490.72%96.78%
- 24The Room Three13,44990.62%95.34%
- 25Crow Country8,33790.53%98.04%
- 26F.E.A.R.19,56990.48%93.65%
- 27Yog-Sothoth’s Yard13,87290.44%94.23%
- 28Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines15,38790.41%94.41%
- 29Quake II10,42890.39%95.38%
- 30POSTAL: Brain Damaged11,24490.34%94.93%
- 31Rusty Lake Hotel10,61890.31%96.00%
- 32Five Nights at Freddy's: Into the Pit10,96890.26%95.73%
- 33Trepang219,62790.18%92.73%
- 34Devil Daggers9,50290.13%95.34%
- 35A Castle Full of Cats4,52889.95%99.18%
- 36KinitoPET14,76889.87%93.04%
- 37Viscera Cleanup Detail23,76589.84%92.19%
- 38Amnesia: The Bunker12,63289.70%93.28%
- 39Five Nights at Freddy's 417,00189.69%92.89%
- 40Aliens vs. Predator21,68989.65%91.43%
- 41HROT6,52289.65%96.49%
- 42Nothing9,95989.62%94.08%
- 43Psychopomp GOLD5,41289.54%97.60%
- 44Bean Battles10,13289.53%93.83%
- 45Yuppie Psycho: Executive Edition9,54389.49%94.97%
- 46Beacon Pines4,51489.44%97.56%
- 47Yume Nikki10,62589.42%94.28%
- 48The Exit 811,62189.38%92.99%
- 49Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion15,56089.35%92.62%
- 50DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition12,92789.24%93.09%
- 51The Darkness II21,14789.23%91.58%
- 52The Test: Hypothesis Rising5,91989.22%97.58%
- 53Crawl7,32189.16%94.59%
- 54Blasphemous 221,68089.13%90.67%
- 55GORN8,22789.03%93.98%
- 56Little Misfortune14,16789.00%92.34%
- 57The Test: Final Revelation5,36188.99%97.82%
- 58Bendy and the Dark Revival16,34188.98%91.87%
- 59Wolfenstein: The Old Blood23,69688.97%90.32%
- 60Dead Estate6,65888.94%94.59%
- 61Mortal Sin5,88988.86%94.09%
- 62Ravenous Devils9,92188.86%92.56%
- 63DOOM 648,84488.69%92.66%
- 64Rakuen5,93388.68%96.12%
- 65The Supper4,44588.65%98.52%
- 66We Were Here Forever18,93588.63%90.45%
- 67POSTAL14,49088.61%91.60%
- 68Arctic Eggs6,17388.58%95.56%
- 69Choo-Choo Charles17,92288.41%90.73%
- 70POSTAL Redux8,27088.37%92.22%
- 71Lunacid11,57888.35%90.57%
- 72The Binding of Isaac: Afterbirth8,25688.34%93.28%
- 73Oxenfree12,12188.18%91.40%
- 74Salt and Sanctuary21,91788.15%89.36%
- 75AI: The Somnium Files9,41988.12%91.49%
- 76Jump King13,42788.08%89.79%
- 77港詭實錄ParanormalHK20,56487.98%89.35%
- 78House of Detention10,62287.84%90.58%
- 79A Game About Digging A Hole20,12287.63%89.31%
- 80Serious Sam: Siberian Mayhem5,25287.58%92.16%
- 81INMOST7,36987.55%90.76%
- 82Party Hard12,67287.53%90.11%
- 83Axiom Verge6,63287.51%90.12%
- 84Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location12,67587.46%89.99%
- 85KLETKA7,91887.45%90.33%
- 86Five Nights at Freddy's 311,36787.43%90.22%
- 87Dark Deception24,34487.40%88.32%
- 88SEUM: Speedrunners from Hell3,06187.38%94.54%
- 89Terminus: Zombie Survivors4,50587.35%94.21%
- 90WORLD OF HORROR9,85887.35%89.55%
- 91RATSHAKER3,83187.27%92.72%
- 92Ring of Pain5,10387.27%91.36%
- 93The Song of Saya10,25987.23%89.22%
- 94American Arcadia4,27487.20%94.06%
- 95Monstrum3,77587.09%90.57%
- 96VLADiK BRUTAL10,47287.04%89.70%
- 97Max Payne15,88087.03%88.77%
- 98Mister Furry: Hot Muscles4,57787.02%91.57%
- 99BioShock 214,97986.91%88.68%
- 100Zortch1,40086.79%98.29%
