Best Rated Psychological Horror Games Under $5

The best rated Psychological Horror games on Steam for games under $5. Scores are weighted by review volume, so small-sample flukes stay off the list.

By price

Our score adjusts Steam's raw rating for sample size. The fewer reviews a game has, the more its score gets pulled toward the site-wide average, so a tiny game can't fluke its way to #1.
  1. 1Undertale96.18%
  2. 2Doki Doki Literature Club!96.02%
  3. 3WEBFISHING95.89%
  4. 4Buckshot Roulette94.48%
  5. 5Sally Face - Episode One94.12%
  6. 6Little Nightmares94.02%
  7. 7Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk93.93%
  8. 8The Room Two93.73%
  9. 9Ultimate Custom Night93.50%
  10. 10Nubby's Number Factory93.30%
  11. 11Blood and Bacon93.14%
  12. 12Outcore: Desktop Adventure93.14%
  13. 13The Test92.98%
  14. 14Geometry Dash92.93%
  15. 15Tales of the Black Forest92.81%
  16. 16Five Nights at Freddy's92.60%
  17. 17Zup! S92.26%
  18. 18missed messages.91.90%
  19. 19Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator91.83%
  20. 20Pony Island91.58%
  21. 21Cube Escape: Paradox91.56%
  22. 22Find Love or Die Trying91.52%
  23. 23NGU IDLE91.16%
  24. 24Samsara Room91.12%
  25. 25Kindergarten91.04%
  26. 26Crab Game90.99%
  27. 27The Room Three90.98%
  28. 28SCP: Secret Laboratory90.85%
  29. 29Rusty Lake Hotel90.65%
  30. 30Insaniquarium Deluxe90.05%
  31. 31Nothing89.77%
  32. 32Mount Your Friends89.74%
  33. 33Yume Nikki89.70%
  34. 34The Test: Hypothesis Rising89.67%
  35. 35Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion89.64%
  36. 36DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition89.55%
  37. 37The Exit 889.51%
  38. 38The Test: Final Revelation89.47%
  39. 39Quaver89.37%
  40. 40Zup!89.30%
  41. 41Dr. Langeskov, The Tiger, and The Terribly Cursed Emerald: A Whirlwind Heist89.15%
  42. 42The Supper89.14%
  43. 43POSTAL89.02%
  44. 44We Were Here88.54%
  45. 45Cry of Fear88.40%
  46. 46Seen88.30%
  47. 47ULTIMATE MARVEL VS. CAPCOM 388.20%
  48. 48House of Detention88.12%
  49. 49Poppy Playtime87.76%
  50. 50INMOST87.73%
  51. 51Dark Deception87.57%
  52. 52RATSHAKER87.52%
  53. 53Miss Neko 387.50%
  54. 54Duck Simulator 287.40%
  55. 55Mister Furry: Hot Muscles87.39%
  56. 56Paunch87.29%
  57. 57Carpe Diem87.13%
  58. 58Walking Simulator86.61%
  59. 59Open World Game: the Open World Game86.59%
  60. 60Chair F*cking Simulator86.26%
  61. 61That's not my Neighbor86.18%
  62. 62Changed86.07%
  63. 63Pacify85.97%
  64. 64Pool 2D - Poolians85.92%
  65. 65Murky Divers85.89%
  66. 66I Can't Believe It's Not Gambling85.85%
  67. 67Kiosk85.69%
  68. 68Fear Surrounds85.36%
  69. 69Malware85.29%
  70. 70Lunch Lady85.23%
  71. 71[Bober Bros] The Hole85.02%
  72. 72CLICKOLDING84.51%
  73. 73FPS Chess84.43%
  74. 74An alt girl for skoof84.40%
  75. 75Sherlock Holmes The Awakened84.39%
  76. 76Ricochet84.27%
  77. 77Hand Simulator84.13%
  78. 78Adorables83.99%
  79. 79MONMUSU83.61%
  80. 80Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Links83.37%
  81. 81Underworld Idle83.30%
  82. 82Pro Soccer Online82.88%
  83. 83Escape Room - Der kranke Kollege82.86%
  84. 84Professional Fishing82.69%
  85. 85Nuclear Nightmare82.48%
  86. 86ALTF482.41%
  87. 87LASERS82.20%
  88. 88Call of Cthulhu81.67%
  89. 89We Were Here Too81.44%
  90. 90Insanity Clicker80.82%
  91. 91RISK: Global Domination80.51%
  92. 92BLOCKADE79.65%
  93. 93Real Pool 3D - Poolians79.05%
  94. 94AdVenture Communist78.76%
  95. 95RUSSIAPHOBIA78.26%
  96. 96Garten of Banban67.23%
  97. 97FlatOut 3: Chaos & Destruction65.22%
  98. 98Business Tour - Board Game with Online Multiplayer62.51%